You should shop around through your local auto parts stores and alternator service shops for the best price and warranty on an remanufactured unit. You should be able to greatly undercut the prices you stated and possibly get a lifetimw warranty along with it.
I tried the route where I replaced the brushes for just a few dollars and the hands-on labor and time to replace them. That lasted a "few" thousand miles, but an alternator as old as the 250,000 mile unit I was working with was more easily replaced with a lifetime warranted remanufactured unit from O'Reilly's for about $68. Even if it goes out, the alternator is so easy to replace that I won't cry about it.