Can you link me to Toolman's post that you're referring to?
http://www.shoforum.com/showthread.php?p=815304#post815304
The compressor map really only matches efficiency with a PR and flow level, and tell you when you'll see damaging surge or overspeed. The turbine wheel and housing really are just as important to matching a turbo to an engine and you can't get any info on that from a compressor map.
Yes, I agree, as you will notice in the above noted thread.
I've never run a Holset on any of my personal cars, but I have seen firsthand the impressive results some are having with them. Take it or leave it, my post above was only for consideration, not to be taken as gospel. I'll now graciously concede to the members here that have extensive SHO specific experience.
I am sure that some users have had great experiences with sourcing turbo's from junkyard diesels. The reason some on this site have heard me suggest against this practice is not because there are no diesel turbo's that will work for a SHO, but simply because many on the internet simply find an old 1-ton truck and think that because it had a turbo and made 'mad torque', that it will be perfect for their wants. As the referenced thread brings out, it pays to educate oneself to a decently thorough degree concerning turbocharger choice, and what kind of duty they want their SHO to serve. In the end, since turbocharger selection can have a large outcome on the enjoyment of your project, and since the supporting mods can end up costing well into the thousands (forged pistons, large injectors, tuning device, piping, WG, oil and vac lines, boost controller, intercooler, MAF, plus all the other items that need to be addressed on most SHOs - 60k maintenance, susp, brakes, etc), selecting a turbocharger based on it's cheap price and availability in your nearest salvage, well, that may not always be the best route.
But as evidenced by some of the turbo SHO's on this site (I believe we are up to around 11or 12), a diesel sourced turbo can make loads of HP, and bring a great amount of enjoyment. That said, my current turbo is a brand new unit picked specifically for my powerplant, and if your needs dictate and your budget allows, that route is the one I usually reccomend.
Welcome to the site! I am far from a turbo expert, or even a SHO expert, but having put a few miles on mine, I was forced to educate myself somewhat, and I simply try to share what I have learned with others on the forum. We can always use people with knowledge and experience, and I am sure we can learn some things from yours. BTW, what brings you to the forum? Planning a turbo SHO build?
