Billy P:
Let me help. I already talked with Tirerack about the same thing. They recommended the Dunlop P5000 for agressive driving. I wanted to go with the Conti Extreme Contact, but they didn't have them in our size and they said the tire "hasn't been proven" yet. Since it is a relatively new tire, there has not been enough feedback to give it a firm rating. However, I checked with Tires.com and they had the Extreme Contact rated at 4.5 out of 5 stars in almost every category, to include driving in light snow. All the customer feedback indicated the tire was doing well. Also it had the highest treadwear rating of all the tires I looked at in the high performance category. I have the P5000 because Tirerack did not have the Extreme Contact on hand. They were $10 more each. You can get the Extreme Contact for like $78 per tire. A good deal as far as I can tell. Of course, you could go with the Tirerack recommendation and get a proven tire like the P5000 for $89 each and you're still getting a very good deal.