I hadn't stepped back in this thread since I have no plans to modify a FWD 4500 lb sedan, so all the bickering of the tuner tribes was getting old and pointless.
Come back a month later and it seems like GH finally jumped in and "brought the tech" - kind of. They stated they use the factory knock setup to infer octane levels, just as I postulated, but they tweaked the software to work faster and to actually affect boost levels. OK, nice job adding some capabilities to the tune. Seriously. I don't doubt that it works better with changes in octane than other tuner's software strategies and GH should be applauded for that.
But still though, there is no reading or measuring of octane levels in any way. The ECU is still waiting for knock to occur, then adjusting the timing and boost, in the same way the factory does, but with some enhancements as to what is affected.
I know this is pointless to even discuss since you guys are high on GH tunes and I'll be dismissed as a "SSI troll" ( for the record I have NO clue who SSI even is) - but given that no actual octane measurement is performed in any way and your engine has to experience knock for he "auto octane" to actually adjust anything, in my opinion, the auto octane thing is still a gimmick. The engine still has to experience knock, then pull back until it stops, which still damages bearing and rings.
It's too bad there's not a simple inline device that can measuring octane of the fuel like we can get with the gas/alcohol mix %.
For the record, I don't give a rat's ass about who buys what tune or whose parts. It's your car- have at it with anything you want. You can tune it with a fork for all I care. I was just trying to get some actual tech on this "AO" stuff since this forum is the only place I've ever seen it discussed over 30 years of owning/modifying and tuning Fords.